Official: $1.2M spent so far will be recouped in less than a year with property taxes
FISHERS, Ind. — Town officials on Thursday defended the amount they’ve spent in the long fight to annex Geist homeowners, even as both sides braced for a courtroom showdown.
Fishers’ leaders a day earlier revealed records showing they have paid six law firms, two accountants, a city planner and a legislative consultant more than $1,243,070 since January 2007 in their pursuit of 2,200 homes near and on Geist Reservoir.
“This is a one-time cost to correct a long-term inequity,” said Town Council President Scott Faultless. “It will take less than a year to make this back.”
A majority of the Geist residents oppose annexation and have sued Fishers to prevent it.
Fishers sought help in various areas — planning the annexation, beating back residents’ attempts to create two new towns and successfully battling an anti-annexation bill in the General Assembly, records released by the town show. The costs range from $253,786 to the law firm of Bose McKinney & Evans, to $133,437 to the Indianapolis public relations company of Sease, Gerig & Associates.
Representatives of the homeowners’ group Geist United Opposition declined to comment on Fishers’ costs. But its members have said the town’s spending was reckless in the unfriendly annexation attempt.
The annexation fight has cost the homeowners about $100,000 in legal bills.
Town officials say their legal costs are worth it because the town will gain millions in property taxes from the homeowners for years to come if the annexation succeeds.
“This is about forever,” said Town Council member Stuart Easley.
Fishers projects it will reap $10.2 million in property taxes — after deducting for the cost of added services — in the first five years of annexation.
Town officials said almost all their annexation expenses came after homeowners last summer rejected Fishers’ attempt to annex them voluntarily.
“People should know that barely any of these costs are related to the annexation itself but instead to defending ourselves on all these other fronts,” said Bryan Babb, an attorney for Indianapolis-based Bose McKinney. If the homeowners had agreed to the annexation, the cost would have been about $100,000, he said.
The town offered three-year tax abatements and pledges of free sewer hook ups to the homeowners if they agreed to annexation. Instead, Geist United rejected the offer and went to court last September to incorporate as its own towns, East Geist and West Geist.
During that skirmish, which ended in December, Fishers spent $330,152. Included in the costs were $23,081 to Carmel-based Wabash Scientific, an urban planning firm that did a report on what services Fishers could provide to Geist, and $37,099 to Greenwood-based Reedy & Peters, an accounting firm that determined how those services would be paid for.
After a judge ruled that the homeowners couldn’t incorporate, the homeowners found a sponsor for a legislative bill that would ban involuntary annexations.
The town spent $228,135 fighting the bill, including $42,000 to the Indianapolis law firm Barnes & Thornburg for legislative monitoring and evaluation and $16,679 to Sease, Gerig.
Geist is at least the fourth metro area in recent years to challenge annexation.
Carmel last year successfully annexed 8.3 square miles in southwest Clay Township in a case that went to the Indiana Supreme Court. Carmel is in another fight to annex the community of Home Place, which is just north of Indianapolis.
Thursday, Greenwood sued Bargersville in Johnson County to stop the city from annexing a piece of unincorporated land near Greenwood’s border. Participants in those lawsuits doubted the Geist annexation would have any effect on theirs.
Fishers and the Geist homeowners are scheduled to appear before Hamilton Superior Court Judge Steven Nation on Oct. 1.
Source: http://www.indystar.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20080919/LOCAL0102/809190439/1175/LOCAL0102